The Difference Between Emotional Support Dogs And Service Dogs

Service dogs are those that are trained to assist or carry out work for people with disabilities such as sensory, psychiatric, mental, and intellectual disabilities. Some of the tasks they perform include pulling a wheelchair, reminding someone to take medications, or even altering their sound.

Also read:

According to the Americans with Disabilities (ADA) Title II and Title III, comfort animals, therapy dogs, and emotional support animals are not service dogs. This is because service dogs only perform tasks that are directly related to the person’s stability. Even if the doctor writes to a person that they need an emotional support dog, they still do not qualify to be called a service dog.

What is a service dog?

According to ADA, a service animal is a dog that has undergone training to enable it to assist people with disabilities. But the dog must also be related to the specific disability.

Service Dogs and the ADA

People with disabilities are usually unable to perform some routine tasks in their life. Therefore, they require service dogs that are trained to help them with specific tasks i.e. in the case of an autistic child from walking away or a person with hearing loss, the dog will help notice if anyone is following him from behind.

According to the US Department of Justice, there are many questions about ADA and service animals. The department states that all agencies, businesses, and select NGOs should make some goods or services in such a way that people with disabilities will find it easier to use them. This also applied to service dogs, and it states that even if a company does not allow dogs on its premises, then it should allow the service dogs as they are helpful to people with disabilities.

Emotional Dog

Emotional dogs, unlike service dogs, offer comfort to their owner just by being present. Since they offer comfort, they are not considered service dogs since this is not a necessity. Also, unlike service dogs, they do not undergo any specialized training.

These dogs are ideal for people with emotional or psychological disabilities and are the best companions. If you are suffering from anxiety, panic attacks, depression, or other emotional and psychological conditions, then the law allows you to get an emotional dog. They are also used in therapy sessions to improve the intellectual and psychiatric disabilities of the owners.

Are Emotional Support Dogs Allowed Access to Public Areas?

Since emotional support dogs do not undergo professional training, they do not fall under the ADA category. The service dogs, on the other hand, are trained to perform some tasks and help people with disabilities. Therefore, since the emotional support dog does not enjoy ADA laws protection, they are not allowed to access public places such as hospitals, restaurants, and public theatres.

But they are allowed to stay in the apartments even for those with no dog policies, and you can board the plane with them. Emotional support dogs play an important role in individuals with emotional or psychiatric disabilities. However, they do not service animals and are therefore not permitted in some areas though you will still enjoy some rights and exceptions.

What Is The Difference Between An Emotional Support Dog And A Service Dog

For many people, dogs are more than just pets—they’re true companions. Dogs can provide emotional support and affectionate companionship, and they can also be trained to perform specific tasks that assist their owners in daily life. Here’s a look at the difference between two types of assistance dogs: emotional support dogs and service dogs.

Emotional support dogs are animals that provide a source of comfort and companionship for people with mental health conditions or other emotional issues. These dogs are not trained to perform specific tasks, but their very presence can help to reduce anxiety, ease depression, and promote a sense of well-being. Unlike service dogs, emotional support dogs do not need to be trained to perform specific tasks.

Service dogs, on the other hand, are specially trained to perform specific tasks that their owners may struggle with due to physical or mental disabilities. Common service dog tasks include guiding blind owners, providing mobility assistance, fetching items, flipping light switches, and even providing life-saving medical alerts. In order to be eligible for public access rights, service dogs must undergo extensive training and be certified by an accredited organization.

So, what’s the difference between an emotional support dog and a service dog? Emotional support dogs provide companionship and emotional support but are not trained to perform specific tasks. Service dogs are specially trained to provide assistance with everyday activities and perform essential tasks.

The Purpose Of An Emotional Support Dog/Service Dog

Emotional support dogs (ESDs) provide companionship and love to people who may be experiencing anxiety, depression, or other mental health disorders. These furry friends can help to ease feelings of loneliness, provide comfort during difficult times, and offer unconditional love that can be invaluable to those struggling with their mental health. In addition to providing emotional support, ESDs can also be trained to perform specific tasks that can help their owners manage their disorder. For example, a dog might be trained to remind their owner to take medication, provide deep pressure therapy during a panic attack, or alert them to an impending seizure. Service dogs (SDs), on the other hand, are specifically trained to perform certain tasks that assist their owners with physical disabilities. 

These tasks might include opening doors, retrieving items, or providing balance assistance. SDs undergo extensive training and are required to meet high standards of behavior in order to perform their jobs effectively. Unlike ESDs, SDs have public access rights and are allowed to accompany their owners in places where pets are typically not allowed. While both ESDs and SDs can offer valuable assistance to those in need, it’s important to remember that they are not the same thing. Before getting a dog, it’s important to do your research and make sure you are getting the right type of support for your needs.

Photo of author

Peter Newman

Peter Newman is the owner and editor for Puppy Leader. He has two dogs and loves to train them daily. Every day, Peter takes his dogs to the park and lets them run around and play together. He also trains them each day with different commands and tricks.